Rockland County Executive Ed Day sharply criticized a federal court ruling that struck down New York State’s “Save the Hudson” law, calling the decision a “travesty” that threatens decades of environmental progress along the river. The law, enacted last year, was designed to block Holtec International, the company responsible for decommissioning the Indian Point nuclear plant, from releasing radioactive wastewater into the Hudson. The court ruled that federal law preempts state restrictions, effectively giving Holtec the green light to proceed.
Day said the ruling ignores the remarkable strides made in restoring the Hudson River, pointing to the return of bald eagles, sturgeon, and even dolphins as evidence of the river’s revival. “Allowing Holtec to discharge contaminated water would undo decades of progress and be nothing short of a travesty for our environment, our communities, and future generations,” he said.
The decision is the latest development in a long battle between local communities, environmental groups, and Holtec. Critics warn that dumping radioactive waste into the river threatens not only wildlife but also drinking water supplies, recreation, and the economic vitality of the region. Billions of dollars have been invested in cleaning up the Hudson over the past four decades, turning it into a symbol of environmental recovery in New York. Holtec maintains that any releases will meet federal safety standards, but opponents argue that no additional contamination should be permitted.
Environmental advocates fear the ruling weakens the ability of states to protect their own waterways from nuclear-related discharges. Day and other officials are now calling on Congress and federal regulators to take action to safeguard the Hudson, while advocacy groups prepare to continue the fight through appeals and public campaigns. “The Hudson River is not just a body of water,” Day said. “It’s part of our identity, our economy, and our future. We cannot stand idly by while decades of progress are put at risk.”